Is work supplanting religion in Silicon Valley? Sociologist Carolyn Chen questions if the Valley’s extended working hours, complimentary dining options, and mindfulness sessions have substituted traditional religious practices and communal bonds. She delves into the reasons why organized religion struggles to establish roots in this tech hub and how technology companies leverage spiritual concepts to enhance their profits. In her analysis, she presents a compelling argument showcasing the diluted version of religion through the commercialization of sacred Buddhist rituals.
Notably, as documented by Robert Putnam in his 2009 work “Bowling Alone,” the decline in community engagement and religious commitment is not solely attributable to Silicon Valley, but is a pervasive trend affecting society at large, even within the Valley itself. Speculating on whether tech enthusiasts will continue venerating work in the face of significant staff layoffs and the cessation of complimentary meals would necessitate a crystal ball in Chen’s possession.
- Key Points
- Synopsis
- For a significant portion of Silicon Valley professionals, “work is becoming their religion.”
- When individuals yearn for a spiritual existence but can hardly allot time for it, they may discover a form of religiosity in their professional roles.
- Youthful tech professionals from distant locales frequently derive their identity from their work; their coworkers assume the role of surrogate family.
- Battling burnout represents a prevalent challenge within the tech sector.
- Perks at tech companies serve as a magnet for retaining top engineers.
- Journeys of introspection may lead employees to realize they are in the wrong profession.
- Integrating meditation and mindfulness at work can inadvertently reduce Buddhism to mere “secular mindfulness.”
- “Techtopia,” an environment where individuals derive ultimate fulfillment from their occupations, has arisen from the tech sector’s transformation of religious practices.
- About the Author
- Review
- Key Themes
Key Points
- For a considerable number of Silicon Valley professionals, “work is becoming their religion.”
- Individuals seeking a spiritual existence but lacking the time for traditional religious practices may discover a sense of devotion within their professional endeavors.
- Immigrant tech professionals often derive their sense of self from their work, viewing their coworkers as surrogate family members.
- Experiencing burnout poses a significant challenge within the technology sector.
- The attractive perks offered by tech companies play a crucial role in attracting and retaining skilled engineers.
- An individual’s journey of self-exploration might reveal mismatched career choices.
- The utilization of meditation and mindfulness techniques at the workplace may incorrectly oversimplify the essence of Buddhism to mere “secular mindfulness.”
- The emergence of “Techtopia,” a society where individuals derive ultimate fulfillment from their work, stems from the tech industry’s disruption of conventional religious practices.
Synopsis
For a significant portion of Silicon Valley professionals, “work is becoming their religion.”
Individuals in Silicon Valley are shifting away from conventional religion and replacing it with work endeavors that provide a sense of “belonging, identity, purpose, and transcendence.” Instead of seeking existential meaning, moral guidance, and ethical norms in religious settings, individuals are now seeking these elements in their professional sphere.
As one observer aptly phrased it, “Meaning has become the new currency.” This pursuit of meaning motivates individuals to seek a sense of community in their work. Surveys indicate that a staggering 90% of individuals would willingly accept reduced salaries if their work offered a greater sense of purpose.
Stressed tech professionals find a form of spirituality through employer-sponsored mindfulness sessions, lectures, and retreats within the workplace. Many prominent corporations invest in their employees’ spiritual well-being as part of their benefits package. Some major tech firms engage meditation instructors, extending this trend beyond Silicon Valley, with approximately 22% of US companies incorporating mindfulness practices for their staff.
“When asked about the sources of meaning in their lives, 34% of Americans cited ‘career,’ making work one of the primary wellsprings of meaning for Americans, ranking second only to family (69%).”
Professionals in Silicon Valley often highlight how their demanding 60-hour workweeks present challenges in maintaining religious commitments. To excel in the tech realm, individuals must dedicate significant time and resources to their professional pursuits. Tech startups strive to instill a sense of purpose in their employees, a mission that can assume quasi-religious dimensions.
When individuals yearn for a spiritual existence but can hardly allot time for it, they may discover a form of religiosity in their professional roles.
American corporations aim to foster a familial culture and cultivate a sense of community among their team members, foreseeing potential gains from these efforts. However, increased work commitments often erode the foundations of traditional societal institutions like religious congregations. In 1990, 91% of Americans professed a religious affiliation, a figure that dwindled to 77% by 2018. This decline extends beyond religious practices to impact broader community engagement.
Involvement in various civic groups has markedly decreased since the 1970s. As individuals increasingly invest their identity in their careers, they tend to withdraw from conventional societal structures such as religious affiliations. Prioritizing work over other aspects of life, such as spiritual devotion, a balanced lifestyle, and engagement in non-professional communities, has become a common trend.
Many tech professionals express the challenges of maintaining religious practices amidst their demanding workloads. Religious individuals residing in Silicon Valley often find themselves required to be exceptionally devout to sustain active participation.
“A majority of Fortune 500 companies incorporate fundamental features akin to religious institutions — a defined mission, core values, established practices, ethical standards, and a foundational ‘origin story.’ ”
Some individuals who were active participants in religious communities elsewhere in the US relinquish their prior religious customs upon relocating to Silicon Valley, where their professional obligations supersede their religious affiliations. Conversely, those anchored in local religious circles — typically older individuals with established familial ties beyond their workplace — resist the allure of tech industry sanctity. These “skeptics” adhere to their prior religious practices and can disentangle themselves from the influence of their profession.
Many perceive the Silicon Valley ethos as conflicting with their religious convictions, yet individuals who disengage from organized religion often do so inadvertently, gradually drifting away rather than making a conscious departure.
Youthful tech professionals from distant locales frequently derive their identity from their work; their coworkers assume the role of surrogate family.
Young tech engineers, often unattached, geographically separated from home, receptive, and impressionable, find themselves drawn into the narrative of their work environment. Spending the majority of their waking hours at the office, their primary social interactions revolve around their colleagues, fostering a belief in the sacredness of their work. Tech professionals exhibit unwavering faith in the outcomes of their labor. Analogous to religious communities necessitating adherence to specific beliefs, tech companies require employees to subscribe to their corporate ethos.
“The ‘spiritual’ connections forged among coworkers echo the depth of relationships cultivated in another institution known for fostering intimate bonds: the family.”
Many Silicon Valley professionals relocating from distant regions regard their coworkers as akin to family, with a sense of “moral duty” to their work family preventing them from slacking. The company narrative becomes intertwined with their personal identity, rendering them unable to refuse any request. Displaying loyalty becomes a badge of honor in Silicon Valley, demanding complete alignment from all employees.
Battling burnout represents a prevalent challenge within the tech sector.
In tech companies, spiritual practices such as meditation and yoga have become as ubiquitous as complementary meals and onsite fitness facilities, all geared towards mitigating burnout. However, given the industry norm of a demanding 60-hour workweek, burnout remains pervasive. The toll exacted by burnout affects the mental and physical well-being of tech professionals, compromising their productivity, a significant concern for their organizations. Despite the financial costs associated with paid leave and medical expenses, companies prioritize employee welfare and endorse wellness initiatives under the belief that “investing in employee well-being yields returns.”
Tech engineers, driven by their work commitments, often overlook self-care practices. In 2000, Susan Lamott, Vice President of Talent and Development at Tech Pointe, established a firm specializing in “corporate maternalism,” assisting companies in nurturing their employee’s individual requirements through offering amenities like meals, yoga sessions, mindfulness retreats, and personal development workshops. In exchange for this form of investment, firms anticipate their employees to excel.
“Previously, the human resources department used to manage employees defensively by ‘shielding the company from its employees,’ as one individual phrased it, through enforcing adherence. Now, Human Resources ‘safeguards’ the company by looking after its most valuable resources, its highly skilled employees.”
In Silicon Valley, achieving a true equilibrium between work and personal life is uncommon because employees spend the majority of their active hours within the workplace premises. Companies take on the responsibility of supporting their staff to extract more productive hours from each individual. Assisting employees in avoiding burnout ultimately enables them to enhance their performance.
Companies entice, cultivate, and preserve top-notch engineers by providing extravagant benefits as part of a fierce strive to compete in the recruitment market. Big tech firms caught up in “the war for talent” have grasped from their experiences that engineers may depart an organization over perks. Certain major corporations, such as Google, have designed their work environments with features like eateries, meditation areas, art studios, libraries, and other facilities to ensure that their staff feel no necessity to leave the premises. Google addresses the personal needs of employees by providing conveniences like on-site childcare and laundry services so that they can continue working. The boundary separating work from personal life is not just vague but virtually imperceptible. However, numerous employees do not make use of corporate perks, aside from complimentary meals.
Perks at tech companies serve as a magnet for retaining top engineers.
Companies pit themselves against each other to offer a broad range of indulgences and incentives. They aim for their employees to be content, or at the very least appear content. Nevertheless, no yoga lesson or a platter of complimentary snacks can remedy the toll that sixteen-hour workdays take on an individual. As workloads intensify, workforces become leaner. Irrespective of how earnestly a nurturing corporation endeavors to ensure the well-being of its employees, profits always remain the foremost priority.
During significant transitions such as takeovers, stress can propel employees into a state of “change fatigue.” Frequently, human resources departments provide meditation and mindfulness courses to alleviate the effect of corporate changes. Coaching for executives, an industry that has seen exponential growth in Silicon Valley dating back to the ’60s, is widely prevalent. Executives and managers seek the services of coaches to aid their staff in “connecting with their authentic selves” and becoming more proficient in their roles.
Nonetheless, a majority of individuals do not establish a strong connection with their occupations, leading to feelings of alienation in the workplace. Predominantly, organizations recognize alienation and burnout as issues stemming from corporate culture rather than attributing blame to the employees.
“Expansion entails nurturing and tending to a living entity. It requires diligent care each day, not simply inundating it with large volumes of resources all at once and then revisiting it after six months. No, it necessitates a consistent effort each day. It needs fertile soil and adequate nourishment. It takes time.” (Hector Gomez, human resources professional)
Generally, firms reserve coaching and programs emphasizing spiritual development for executives and other high-potential personnel. The objective for coaches is to bolster the engagement and enjoyment levels of employees in high-ranking positions, assisting them in finding meaning in their roles. Previously, a company viewed an executive in need of coaching as someone whose performance was deteriorating. In the contemporary scenario, having a personal coach is perceived as a status symbol.
Journeys of introspection may lead employees to realize they are in the wrong profession.
Corporations sponsor programs related to meditation and training to augment employees’ devotion to work rather than facilitating their alignment with a higher calling, although this might inadvertently occur. The new generation of Silicon Valley inhabitants approaches religious practices akin to technology; individuals do not prioritize the spiritual dimension of activities such as yoga and meditation, instead viewing these practices as a means to an end — the ultimate goal being enhanced productivity at work.
“Considering work as a form of ‘calling,’ ‘affection,’ and ‘service’ might bring employees closer to their own enlightenment, while also fulfilling the management’s aim of garnering additional returns from labor.”
Many managers value their staff as individuals. They are keen to learn about their personal lives, contribute to their growth, and retain them. Formerly, individuals were associated with a single company for the duration of their careers, earning benefits like pensions that are now almost archaic. Today, a typical tech professional changes jobs every few years, as soon as their tasks become monotonous. Given this trend, employees need to constantly ensure their marketability for future roles while staying updated with the latest technologies and programs in their current jobs. Being marketable involves effectively managing stress and maintaining focus, areas where mindfulness and meditation prove beneficial.
Tech professionals must maintain composure and concentration to navigate through their tasks without being overwhelmed. Some individuals calm their minds by adopting modified Buddhist practices like chanting and breathing exercises. Certain employees adopt the practice of “nonattachment,” a technique aiding in regulating emotions and reducing the impact of stress triggers.
Integrating meditation and mindfulness at work can inadvertently reduce Buddhism to mere “secular mindfulness.”
The tech industry sheds the “religious baggage” associated with faith, a perspective that may lead to the adulteration of Buddhist practices such as meditation into commodities geared towards enhancing productivity amongst employees. Corporate entities often dilute the sacred teachings of Buddhism to boost workforce efficiency. Some firms only engage instructors who offer secular classes, prompting educators to exclude religious components from their teachings to cater to the preferences of larger corporations. As a consequence, prayer beads and incense serve as mundane decor in meditation spaces. Certain individuals misinterpret Buddhism as a mere philosophy or scientific discipline rather than recognizing it as a religion. This interpretation is met with criticism by many Asian Americans, as it undermines the ethical foundations of this venerable religion.
Since the early 2000s, there has been a surge in studies exploring the scientific basis of mindfulness. Numerous mindfulness instructors cite scientific evidence supporting the impact of meditation on productivity. They employ terms like “neuro-self-hacking” to describe mindfulness as a technique fostering increased dedication and efficiency. Despite ongoing debates regarding whether mindfulness sessions genuinely enhance productivity, studies indicate that tech professionals are inclined towards participating in mindfulness classes rooted in credible scientific research.
“One significant example illustrating the secularization of Buddhist meditation is the fact that numerous tech workers must seek a ‘mindful moment’ within the restroom.”
The concept of “on-the-go” Buddhism eradicates the inconvenience associated with traditional religious practices, condensing an entire religion into bite-sized, one-minute fragments, akin to apps claiming to enhance focus and meditation within minutes of usage per day. This representation portrays meditation as a practical tool, though authentic meditation is sacred — entirely distinct from being a mere instrument.
“Techtopia,” an environment where individuals derive ultimate fulfillment from their occupations, has arisen from the tech sector’s transformation of religious practices.
As tech employees’ lives become centered around the workplace, traditional institutions like churches and community organizations witness a decline in their significance and role. Techtopia aims to address this void as employees seek completeness, satisfaction, and purpose. The specialized workforce in Techtopia sets the tone for broader societal trends. When society venerates work, traditional social and community establishments…will start to deteriorate, enabling social and income disparities to expand.
To evade the “dictatorship of labor,” individuals must collectively opt to revere something else, something deserving of reverence, such as family, community, civil society, and religion. This does not imply that society should forsake work. Instead, it should channel vigor into various facets of people’s lives as well. In the words of writer David Foster Wallace, “There is, in fact, no such thing as atheism. There is no such thing as not revering. Everyone reveres. The only choice we have is what to revere.”
About the Author
Carolyn Chen, an associate professor of ethnic studies at the University of California, Berkeley, also penned Getting Saved in America: Taiwanese Immigration and Religious Experience.
Review
In “Work Pray Code: When Work Becomes Religion in Silicon Valley,” Carolyn Chen delves into the captivating and thought-provoking intersection of work culture, spirituality, and technology in the unique context of Silicon Valley. With meticulous research and insightful analysis, Chen scrutinizes how the work environments in the tech industry have transformed into quasi-religious spheres, where employees frequently discover their purpose, identity, and community. This compelling book illuminates the obscured complexities of the Silicon Valley work culture and its repercussions on individuals and society.
Chen guides readers through the intricate terrain of Silicon Valley, where work has surpassed its conventional boundaries and evolved into a form of religious devotion. Through extensive interviews, observations, and analysis, the author examines the rituals, ideologies, and convictions that have arisen within the tech industry. She explores the methods through which companies cultivate a sense of mission and purpose among employees, often blurring the distinction between personal and professional life. Chen also explores the role of technology in molding this work-as-religion phenomenon, exploring the impact of mindfulness practices, digital connectivity, and the perpetual pursuit of innovation.
The book sheds light on the pressures and expectations encountered by those toiling in Silicon Valley, as employees frequently sense an obligation to dedicate excessive time and energy to work, jeopardizing personal well-being and relationships. Chen discusses the influence of this work-centric culture on mental well-being, burnout rates, and the deterioration of work-life balance. Moreover, she examines the consequences of intertwining work and spirituality, such as the potential for exploitation, the reinforcement of hierarchical power structures, and the exclusion of marginalized groups.
Chen also scrutinizes the impact of religious and spiritual practices within the tech industry, encompassing meditation, yoga, and other mindfulness techniques. She probes how these practices have been assimilated and reimagined to align with the values and objectives of the tech realm. Additionally, the author investigates how Silicon Valley’s work culture intersects with broader societal concerns, such as gender disparities, diversity and inclusion, and the ethics of technological advancement.
Throughout the book, Chen preserves an objective and well-balanced perspective, presenting a spectrum of viewpoints and experiences. She adeptly intertwines personal anecdotes, sociological scrutiny, and historical context to construct a comprehensive and sophisticated comprehension of the subject matter. The book encourages readers to critically analyze the work culture in Silicon Valley and prompts contemplation on the equilibrium between work, personal gratification, and societal principles.
Key Themes
- The Emergence of Techno-Spirituality: Chen posits that the tech industry has evolved into a novel form of religious establishment, with a culture that blurs the boundaries between work and spirituality. Tech behemoths like Google, Facebook, and Apple are perceived as hallowed precincts where employees can discover meaning and purpose in their work. This techno-spirituality is fueled by the belief that technology can resolve societal challenges and inaugurate a utopian future.
- The Adulation of the Entrepreneur: Chen scrutinizes the cultural luminaries of Silicon Valley, such as Steve Jobs and Elon Musk, who are venerated for their innovative concepts and their capacity to revolutionize industries. These entrepreneurs are viewed as contemporary prophets, whose vision and guidance can revolutionize the world. This adulation of the entrepreneur has spawned a fresh form of religious hierarchy, with tech titans at the zenith and small startups aspiring to join their ranks.
- The Rites of Coding: Chen dissects the rituals and customs of coding, which have metamorphosed into a form of spiritual practice in the tech industry. Programmers perceive coding as a form of contemplation, a means to connect with the divine through the act of creation. The author contends that these rituals are not solely technical exercises but a method to access a higher state of consciousness.
- The Implications on Work-Life Balance: Chen raises crucial inquiries about the implications of techno-spirituality on work-life balance. As work becomes increasingly sanctified, it can be arduous to disengage from the demands of work, culminating in burnout and fatigue. The author posits that this can have momentous repercussions for employees’ mental and physical health, in addition to their relationships outside of work.
“Work Pray Code: When Work Becomes Religion in Silicon Valley” is a meticulously investigated and thought-provoking examination of the convergence of work, spirituality, and technology in the backdrop of Silicon Valley. Carolyn Chen’s narrative style is approachable and engrossing, rendering intricate concepts and theories accessible to both academic and general readers.
One of the strengths of this book lies in Chen’s capacity to present an equitable perspective. She does not approach the subject matter with a preconceived bias but rather permits the voices of those toiling in Silicon Valley to be heard, while also critically evaluating the potential pitfalls and adverse consequences of the work-as-religion phenomenon. This impartial approach lends credence to her analysis and encourages readers to formulate their own assessments.
Furthermore, the extensive research undertaken by Chen is apparent throughout the book. The inclusion of interviews, case studies, and historical context furnishes a rich tapestry of insights into the Silicon Valley work culture. The author’s ability to link individual experiences to broader societal and cultural trends enriches the book’s impact and relevance.
One minor critique is that at times, the book may delve into excessive detail, which could conceivably overwhelm some readers. However, this methodical approach also guarantees that no facet of the subject matter is disregarded, rendering it a comprehensive resource for those intrigued by the topic.
Strengths:
- Chen’s scripting is coherent and captivating, making the book approachable to a broad audience.
- The publication is well-explored, with a plethora of instances and case studies from Silicon Valley firms.
- Chen raises essential queries about the effect of work-pray code on employees and society, and prompts readers to think critically about the role of work in their lives.
Weaknesses:
- Some readers might feel the book’s emphasis on Silicon Valley is too limited, wishing for more instances from other sectors or locales.
- Chen’s argument could be sturdier if she presented more tangible instances of how the work-pray code is impacting employees and society, rather than just highlighting the apt risks and consequences.
Implications:
Chen’s book has notable repercussions for our comprehension of the modern workplace. Initially, it accentuates the necessity to acknowledge the spiritual aspects of work and to establish areas for employees to explore their own spirituality. Secondly, it questions the traditional notion of work-life balance, indicating that the division between work and personal life is increasingly blending. Lastly, it raises crucial queries about the effect of techno-spirituality on society as a whole, notably in terms of the distribution of power and resources.
Conclusion:
In essence, “Work Pray Code: When Work Becomes Religion in Silicon Valley” is a persuasive and perceptive scrutiny of the convergence of work, spirituality, and technology. Carolyn Chen provides a nuanced examination of the Silicon Valley work culture, urging readers to ponder the societal implications of work-centric values and the potential repercussions for individuals and communities. Whether you are well-versed in the tech industry or simply fascinated by the intersection of work and spirituality, this publication delivers a valuable and thought-provoking expedition of a noteworthy contemporary trend.